A week down in Mumbai and here are my first words on a word file. This has to do with one of my own previous posts, Reason.
In the course of that argument, I tried to present the idea that reason was paramount and everything stemmed from that. Even though even now I hold that thought dear, I was shown that reason, though being paramount is not absolute. The reason being there is a limit up to which reason can go.
During the course of this present argument, I shall play the devil’s advocate, a role I do well. The defendant is one who thinks that reason is paramount, namely, me.
Devil’s Advocate (henceforth DA): Which is bigger faith or reason?
Poor Ol’ Me (henceforth POM) : Reason
DA: Why?
POM: Because faith arises when reason fails
DA: Elucidate
POM: Go and read my article called Reason, or something like that
DA: Have read that and that is the reason I come to you
POM: In spite of reading that, do you still have doubts? You must be one gigantic *!@%$#~^&*
DA: We’ll see who is that *!@%$#~^&*
POM: How will this go? Will you ask the question or will I have to? Aka Shivaji in Thiruvilaiyadal (Kaelvigalai nee kaekiraya, ala, naan kaekatuma?)
DA: Me will ask, I cannot answer, aka Nagesh (Nanne kaeakaren, ennaku kaeka than theriyum)
Curious Onlooker: Great, this is a good competition (Ballae, seriyana poetti )
POM: Ask on
DA: Why is reason greater than faith?
POM: Because when reason comes in faith disappears
DA: What is the base of reason?
POM: Reason does not have a base, reason is, therefore, reason is
DA: There you go again, with your lines that no one follow. Who decides reason and how to apply it?
POM: Each individual
DA: Does each person know everything?
POM: No
DA: Then how can his reason be perfect?
POM: I have no clue what you are trying to say
DA: I will ask a question. What is the world made up of?
POM: Matter
DA: What is matter made up of?
POM: Protons, neutrons and electrons
DA: What are they made of?
POM: Quarks and neutrinos
DA: Have you ever seen a quark?
POM: No
DA: Have you ever seen a neutrino?
POM: No
DA: Have you ever done any experiment to show that matter consists of those three particles, protons, neutrons, and electrons?
POM: No
DA: Then how can you argue with me that matter has that?
POM: I know this because I read it somewhere that someone did some experiment. The name of those people who did the experiment is not important, but the result is. The conclusion of that experiment is that matter has those particles.
DA: That means that you are taking it on the belief that person was faultless in the experiment, and so where the thousands who followed him and did the same thing.
POM: Yes
DA: That means that you are going by faith, faith on that person and his scientific abilities
POM: I think so
DA: Even that, my dear, you thinking so, is faith
POM: Cut the crap and tell me what it is you are trying to say
DA: Like, how in religion, faith departs when reason comes in, there will come a time when reason shall fail. This can be because the knowledge of man which he has to apply to arrive at the reason shall become null and void, or the cognitive ability, that which makes him think shall dry out, or the limits that are enforced on his activities by his environment will take a turn for the worse. When I say this, I mean that he will not be able to reason further than what he has so far. When such a state is arrived, reason fails. Any progress that man makes after this is based not on reason, but only faith. It is faith that makes me think that the universe is a result of a big bang, just as it is faith that tells you that there is a god.
Faith is not supreme, neither is reason. It is a loop. One cannot exist with the other, but then one cannot exist without the other as well. Faith, even though blind, needs to have a reason, a cause, and a justification. Reason, even though more objective, even though more cognitive, needs faith, faith on works done before and faith on us, for it is us who reason.
Faith in reason,
Reason in faith.
Both are alone,
Both are together.
Bring one,
The other dies.
Remove one,
The other is dead.
Disclaimer: I had this actual conversation with two people, one showed me that reason is faith, and the other showed me faith is reason. I guess that I shall be forever indebted to them for this post.